Welcome to Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Located in Altamonte Springs, Florida, Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant is a beloved culinary gem that transports diners straight to New York with its authentic Italian fare. With a warm, family-friendly atmosphere adorned with memorabilia of NY baseball, the restaurant captivates patrons like Scott B, who praises its delicious food and inviting vibe. Signature dishes, such as the exquisite gnocchi and renowned New York-style pizza, have earned rave reviews from guests, including Celindabeth Frumento and Angel Mundo. The attentive staff, led by Papa Joe himself, ensures a memorable dining experience, making Papa Joe's a must-visit for Italian food lovers.
-
1090 Montgomery Rd, Altamonte Springs, FL 32714, United States Hotline: +1 407-774-4300
If you're craving authentic Italian cuisine with a twist of New York charm, look no further than Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, nestled in the heart of Altamonte Springs, Florida. This captivating eatery is not just a restaurant; it's an experience that transports diners back to the bustling streets of Brooklyn, where baseball and pizza reign supreme. Located at 1090 Montgomery Rd, Altamonte Springs, FL 32714, Papa Joe's is easy to find and hard to forget.
From the moment you step inside, you're surrounded by a vibrant atmosphere, showcasing a rich collection of memorabilia that pays homage to New York's baseball legacy. The decor sets the stage for what patrons have come to love about this hidden gem—tantalizing dishes that are thoughtfully crafted and served with a side of hospitality that feels like family.
Feedback from satisfied customers speaks volumes. For instance, Scott B raves, “Once you're inside, you can tell Papa Joe loves his NY baseball teams, new and old. This sets you up for some good NY Italian food.” And he's not alone in his enthusiasm. Celindabeth Frumento was swept away by the gnocchi, calling it “one of the best” she’s had, while hoping for the opportunity to talk to Papa Joe himself during her next visit.
It’s clear that comfort food reigns here. Tony Hoty describes his meal as “one of the most delicious” he’s ever had, proving that Papa Joe’s offers much more than just your average pizzeria fare. Each dish is a delightful exploration of traditional Italian flavors, elevated to high culinary standards. Even fast-paced takeout options offer diners the best of New York pizza, as noted by Angel Mundo, who declares it “the best New York style pizza in town by far!”
But it’s not just about the food. The customer experience is thoughtfully curated, with a staff that goes above and beyond. As Ryan Hartzell notes, the service is “quick and friendly,” making it accessible for everyone, including those with dietary restrictions. From the best pasta fagioli to delectable pizza selections, every bite draws you further into the flavor-filled world at Papa Joe's.
All in all, Papa Joe's Pizza & Italian Restaurant is more than a meal – it’s a community landmark that combines the warmth of familial dining with the buzz of a sports bar feel. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or savoring a full-course Italian feast, each visit promises to be memorable. It’s a place you’ll want to return to again and again, celebrating great food and good company. So, gather your friends or family for an outing at Papa Joe's, and discover why it's considered a culinary treasure in Altamonte Springs.
For reservations or takeout, don’t hesitate to call +1 407-774-4300. Get ready for an unforgettable dining experience!
Once you're inside, you can tell Papa Joe loves his NY baseball teams, new and old. Sets you up for some good NY Italian food. This Boston fan highly recommends Papa Joe's.
I visited yesterday and had Gnocchi. It was one of the best Gnoccis I tried. I was hoping to find Braciole on their menu. Perhaps next time I visit, I get lucky to meet Papa Joe and ask him about it. Michael, our server, was very nice. I really recommend this place 100%
I just had one of the most delicious meals of my entire life. I never expected to have such an incredible high-end Italian meal at the local pizzeria but this place is much more than meets the eye! The staff is so friendly and accommodating. I can’t wait to come back!
Delicious I had it to go. omg, best New York style pizza in town by far! Definitely making this my new go to pizza spot thanks to a good friend that also loves this place. I'll make sure to spread the word of this amazing hidden gem!
First time having pizza here, was 30 years ago! Glad to be back... I felt like i was in a Brooklyn Pizzeria! The pizza was superb and the staff... like family! Thank you Joe, for your hospitality and Devine food!
Wow what a great place! Service was quick and friendly. They were very accommodating to a few dietary restrictions I have without making it hard for me to enjoy great food. The best pasta fagioli I’ve ever had! Highly recommend! Papa Joe and Michael run a great restaurant!
A New York theme throughout the restaurant but I won't hold that against them lol(I'm from Chicago) but the Pizza was great and reasonably priced. If I'm ever back in the area I'll definitely come back. Those that are looking for a good pizza place to just chill and hang out with a friend or two, I'd definitely recommend coming here
Food is always good. I've never had bad service, could be a little update on the table area. The pictures on the wall are awesome....if your a baseball fan, and I am. Will go back again and again.